Warning: PDOStatement::execute() [pdostatement.execute]: SQLSTATE[HY000]: General error: 145 Table './skippy_skippy/h_sessions' is marked as crashed and should be repaired in system/classes/databaseconnection.php line 269
skippy dot net

Baggage feed icon

I want a new laptop bag. I'm somewhat particular though, in that I want a laptop bag that doesn't look like a laptop bag. I don't want to carry something that screams "I have a laptop!". I want to avoid the black, fake leather exterior. I want to avoid the traditional laptop bag form factor. I want to avoid a name brand logo emblazoned on the straps or flaps. I'm also a miser, though, and don't want to pay a lot of money.

I've looked at a couple local shops, but they all seem to carry the same lame selection of laptop bags that look like laptop bags. I refuse to buy online because I want to inspect the bag with my own eyes and hands before purchasing. I want to check the relative size and strength of the straps and handles and fasteners. I want to feel the external surface, and evaluate the internal padding. I want to eyeball the storage capacity of the various pockets for my laptop, its AC adapter, and any miscellaneous gadgets I may want to lug with me. I want to see how it'll feel on my shoulder.

I have a STM 13" Loft bag for my old Averatec laptop. I like it well enough: it doesn't look completely like a laptop bag and it fits the laptop comfortably. It's a little cramped when I add the AC adapter, and there's not a lot of room for many other gadgets. I almost bought a 15" grey Loft bag recently, but decided to wait a little longer to see if I could find something superior.

I also have a LowePro CompuDaypack which is great for taking both the laptop and the DSLR camera, but that's not always what I want to do. Further, the backpack form factor isn't the most convenient for many situations. For example, it was entirely too bulky for me while walking around the IFA consumer electronics show. The CompuDaypack makes for a nice travel accessory, keeping all my precious electronics close at hand in the airport, but is way more than I need for going to meetups and similar events.

I think I would like a laptop bag that looks more like a messenger bag -- something reasonably amorphous that doesn't necessarily declare that there's a laptop inside -- provided it could comfortably hold the laptop secure. Along with the laptop and AC adapter, I also want to be able to carry with me my Flip video camera, possibly a point-and-shoot camera, a few spare batteries for the previous two items, and possibly even a battery charger for the batteries. I'm sure that there are all manner of other things I'll find that I want to take with me at different times, so I want to make sure that my laptop bag is sufficiently accommodating. I don't need crazy iPod integration, or an included laptop cooling pad -- both of which I saw in bags last night at MicroCenter. I want high quality materials and construction that will last me a while (I don't want the shoulder strap or clasps breaking any time soon!), and I want it to look halfway decent so that I can take it with me to business meetings without looking like some kind of dolled up bike courier, but also not so fancy that I look like a corporate stiff when I walk into a coffee shop. I'd like something that's comfortable on my shoulder, and easy to access for when I'm on an airplane.

Nicholas from Crunchgear recommends Crumpler bags. They look like decent enough bags, but a recommendation from a trusted source just isn't sufficient for me: I need to see the bag with my own eyes before I'll buy it. Plus, the Crumpler bags are more than I really want to pay. Jorge Castro recommends Tom Bihn, but Tom Bihn laptop bags are also more expensive than I really want to pay. (I did say I'm a miser, right?) Jorge highlights the lifetime guarantee, which is a nice selling point, but to be honest I've never had a laptop bag break on me before.

What laptop bags do you use and recommend? What are the chances of me finding a local retailer for them, so that I can kick the tires before purchasing?


  • January 1st, 1970
  • Naladahc
    You won't be satisfied until you find a Laptop Bag of Holding!
  • Dr.Nik
    Damn you picky ;) I ended up using an old vintage 1971 slim briefcase that just so happened to fit my 17" dell inspiron and power supply PERFECTLY. So my suggestion is... check vintage stores that have old bags or briefcases.
  • Rick
    You can have this one: http://journal.nearbennett.com/2006/10/28/laptop-briefcase-mod/
  • Prashanth Ramesh
    I dont have much experience as I was not as picky with my laptop bag. Being a student an inexpensive backpack was what I looked for, and I found Targus to offer the most value for money. At least some of their bags should be in stores, are among the cheapest (almost all students who I know have one!), offer sturdy construction, variety of form-factors and did I mention cheap? For the price, you could buy two of them to together satisfy all your needs and still spend less than on others that you talked about.
  • Morydd
    I carry my laptop in an padded sleeve sort of thing I got from Ikea. It fits the laptop and just the laptop perfectly. I keep the power supply along with a few cables (USB, ethernet, etc) in another small bag. I like that because it keeps the laptop protected and the accessories together, but I can thow it in my backpack or any other bag I have.
  • Rich
    My bag is from ebags.com, and they have a wide selection of bags that aren't quite as bulky as mine. Mine has the wheels and is ideal for running across the Atlanta airport - something that I find myself doing on a rather alarmingly frequent basis. But they also have ones that are more appropriate for biking or walking. Not sure if any of them fit your demanding specifications.
  • Elfboy
    You're not a woman are you? My recommendation is to go with one of L.L. Bean's fine backpacks with a laptop sleeve. They are reasonably priced and will basically last forever. There are also many options, and you can choose one based on how much other stuff you want to carry. Of course, being a chick, you might not like this idea.
  • Owen
    I've been hunting for the ultimate "can hold a notebook" bag for a long time. I would like a form factor like this Tom Bihn bag, using the paragliding buckle from this Waterfield bag, and the quick-adjust side-cam from this Timbuktu bag. It needs a sturdy hand-grip above the bag's center of gravity in addition to the shoulder strap. It must be water-repellent and rugged enough to be dragged from a motorcycle for a short distance, but not exceedingly heavy. There must be at least one magazine-sized outside pocket. It should have an outside pocket for a phone that actually fits the bulky PDA phones I tend to buy. It should have key clip with a lanyard that is easily accessed. A reasonable compartmented organizer section for holding mp3 player, headphones, USB cables, chargers is essential. Some inner dividers might be useful, too. I've been conspiring with my dad, who makes boat canvas covers in his spare time, to use his heavy-duty sewing machines to create a bag that meets my specifications. We're in the design phase now.
  • Bob
    Here's the manliest, most functional bag imaginable for $20. http://thesatchelpages.com/where-to-buy-jack-bauers-24-hour-messenger-bag/
  • Rick
    I've been using a backpack from Swiss Travel Products for almost a year now, and that's exceptionally long for me, because most of my bags tend to survive at most three months. I am very satisfied with it, and it has plenty of room for all my other junk (like big and clunky headphones, my iPod, lots of work-related printouts and some USB paraphanelia). I don't think they have any actual stores in the US, so you're out of luck there. Their website is at www.swisstravelproducts.com, the bag I'm using is the Swiss Line - Montana backpack. Good luck finding one that suits your needs!
  • skippy
    Thanks for the suggestions, everyone! Dr. Nik: thanks for that tip. I don't often go thrifting, but there are a few vintage stores nearby that I could easily visit to pick through their offerings. Rick: I have a briefcase, so I could re-create your Frankenstein bag, but it's not the form factor I want in a laptop bag. I want something with a shoulder strap so that I can carry the bag with both hands free. Morydd: thanks for explaining to me the use of those laptop sleeves. I've seen them in the stores and couldn't figure out why anyone would pay money for them. If I'm going to throw my laptop in a regular bag not specifically designed for carrying laptops, I suppose the sleeves suddenly become quite useful. Bob: the Jack Bauer manbag looks like it would just fit my laptop, and the price is certainly right. If it doesn't prove a good enough laptop bag it can still be a useful manbag. Thanks Rich and Rick for the links: I'll peruse their offerings.
  • Halfb8ked
    I have a handful of bags that just didn't work out for me, in general, but were good "single purpose" bags. I should let you peruse through them and see if anything works. I just haven't donated them to goodwill yet. The two I will definitely not part with are Eddie Bauer bags. One has a single extra-wide padded shoulder strap -- I had forgotten I even owned it, but it's almost too small for a 15" laptop: perfect for my old iBook and several 10lb textbooks, and lots of pockets. The other is an Eddie Bauer backpack with extra-padded straps and an extra-padded back and is by far the most comfortable backpack I've ever owned. I've been on a quest to find the right bag since I purchased a laptop 8 years ago. I just hate spending $20-40 only to find out I was wrong *again*.
  • Halfb8ked
    Also -- I've seen discounted bags at Marshall's & TJMaxx, too. The last time I was there, it was all I could do to not buy the Timbuktu they had, but I reminded myself bags are NEVER quite as good as they seem in the store.
  • David
    I like my Jack Spade bag, but that doesn't fit within any of the requirements you want from a bag.
  • sunflower
    Messenger Bag of Holding http://www.thinkgeek.com/computing/bags/aaa5/
  • Kastu
    Make sure you find the right one which fit your shoulders. Sometimes the straps not comfortable and balance that can make any pain on shoulders.

About | Policies | skippy.net

Warning: PDOStatement::execute() [pdostatement.execute]: SQLSTATE[HY000]: General error: 145 Table './skippy_skippy/h_sessions' is marked as crashed and should be repaired in system/classes/databaseconnection.php line 269
Warning: PDOStatement::execute() [pdostatement.execute]: SQLSTATE[HY000]: General error: 145 Table './skippy_skippy/h_sessions' is marked as crashed and should be repaired in system/classes/databaseconnection.php line 269